02-04-2010, 03:23 PM
VERY HONEST OPINION from 2nd attempt PASSER at philly.
Took CS 1st time at Philly in May '09
Fresh off passing scores from Step 1 & CK. Studied for 5 mths straight only with USMLEWORLD + FA . Finished FA + UW atleast 5 times. Memorized neeraj pneumos. FAILED in ICE section cuz of poor data gathering (hx + PE) & piss poor well below ave for Pt Notes. ran out of time atleast 7 out of 12 cases both for 15 mins encounter & 10 min PT Notes. didnt practice with anyone. always typed PN. wrote full sentences that killed me. could not organize DDx & Work Up like I wanted to. It was a disaster. Very pissed seeing my result.
Now completely broke. Borrowed $1200. registered in June. Got the date for Nov '09. I was in redemption mode. took june & July off. Set Aug-Sept-Oct for CS study.
1st thing I did!!!! Threw away FA for long long time. Stayed far away from UW subscription forever.
Went to UMDNJ Book store. Picked up 2 Books. Kaplan 35 CS Cases Book & Kaplan Complex Cases for CS Book as I barely had $80 for books.
Started studying from Aug 10 as I had 3 mths which was lot of time. Red Intro from Both Kaplan books like 6-7 times. Underlined it. Did Both Books over & over & over again atleast 6-7 times. A week B4 the exam, subscribe to CSEvideos.
Looking at my CS result 2nd attempt. I see the difference. cuz I duplicated the exact format for PN Kaplan bullet style. I got very high performance for PN so that really lifted my ICE score.
Kaplan complex cases book helped me a lot cuz I had atleast 3 complex cases on exam & I knew exactly what to do. Kaplan complex cases were much harder than actual exam so I was prepared lot better.
FA is very shallow book for CS. It lacks depth & you end up depending too much on minicases which happened to me on 1st attempt & combine that with UW which does not explain anything but just tells you to just do it. NOT a good combo. Both I found real waste of time.
Kaplan both books. Tells you exactly how & why. & its PN section is da best ever particularly for basic cases. I just duplicated exactly as I typed PN in exam. worked big time. Thank god.
Please, take a break for 2 mths. You need to clear your head. & b4 spending another 1200, please go to your local book store & pick up atleast 1 out of 2 kaplan book & start reading. You'll see a huge difference.
Took CS 1st time at Philly in May '09
Fresh off passing scores from Step 1 & CK. Studied for 5 mths straight only with USMLEWORLD + FA . Finished FA + UW atleast 5 times. Memorized neeraj pneumos. FAILED in ICE section cuz of poor data gathering (hx + PE) & piss poor well below ave for Pt Notes. ran out of time atleast 7 out of 12 cases both for 15 mins encounter & 10 min PT Notes. didnt practice with anyone. always typed PN. wrote full sentences that killed me. could not organize DDx & Work Up like I wanted to. It was a disaster. Very pissed seeing my result.
Now completely broke. Borrowed $1200. registered in June. Got the date for Nov '09. I was in redemption mode. took june & July off. Set Aug-Sept-Oct for CS study.
1st thing I did!!!! Threw away FA for long long time. Stayed far away from UW subscription forever.
Went to UMDNJ Book store. Picked up 2 Books. Kaplan 35 CS Cases Book & Kaplan Complex Cases for CS Book as I barely had $80 for books.
Started studying from Aug 10 as I had 3 mths which was lot of time. Red Intro from Both Kaplan books like 6-7 times. Underlined it. Did Both Books over & over & over again atleast 6-7 times. A week B4 the exam, subscribe to CSEvideos.
Looking at my CS result 2nd attempt. I see the difference. cuz I duplicated the exact format for PN Kaplan bullet style. I got very high performance for PN so that really lifted my ICE score.
Kaplan complex cases book helped me a lot cuz I had atleast 3 complex cases on exam & I knew exactly what to do. Kaplan complex cases were much harder than actual exam so I was prepared lot better.
FA is very shallow book for CS. It lacks depth & you end up depending too much on minicases which happened to me on 1st attempt & combine that with UW which does not explain anything but just tells you to just do it. NOT a good combo. Both I found real waste of time.
Kaplan both books. Tells you exactly how & why. & its PN section is da best ever particularly for basic cases. I just duplicated exactly as I typed PN in exam. worked big time. Thank god.
Please, take a break for 2 mths. You need to clear your head. & b4 spending another 1200, please go to your local book store & pick up atleast 1 out of 2 kaplan book & start reading. You'll see a huge difference.