Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Former resident sues Tulane/BRG IM Residency - egydoc2010
#1
http://batonrougegenerallawsuit.webs.com/

A former first year Internal Medicine Resident of Baton Rouge General filed a 50 page lawsuit on March 19, 2012 against the hospital, Tulane University, and eight staff members, including Program Director Floyd Roberts and CEO Bill Holman demanding $182 Million in compensatory and punitive damages for various violations. Among the counts included are fraud, breach of contract, forgery, negligence and violation of the whistleblower statute which protects an employee's right to object to illegal practices within the workplace. In addition to monetary compensation Dr. Amer is seeking reinstatement, punishment of program superiors responsible for his illegal termination and demands a jury trial.

In this fifty page lawsuit it is alleged that due to a series of complaints filed by Dr. Amer pointing out various ACGME violations including intimidating residents into working over the new ACGME mandated eighty hour work week, patient neglect (it is alleged a patient was not seen by the Hospital Medicine Group for five consecutive days), and reporting fraudulent information to CEO Bill Holman provided in an official hearing about a patient's time of death in order to implicate Dr. Amer and reprimand him for his criticism of the program and his superiors, Dr. Amer was terminated in retaliation for his vocality and in violations of the program's as well as ACGME's policies.
Despite policies to the contrary, Dr. Amer who has always received superior evaluations from not only attending physicians, but patients and peers as well was never put on probation nor made aware of any shortcomings. At his semiannual evaluation in December he was told by Dr.Vatsavai Raju that “everyone is impressed with your knowledge and professionalism,” and that he was, “in good shape.” Ironically, just one month after this evaluation and two weeks after Dr. Amer received a reply to his complaint about various concerning incidents, among them the fraud committed by the GME committee as well as the program director and associate program director, which CEO Bill Holman found “extraneous,” Dr. Amer was put on administrative leave and given a notice of intent to terminate effective March 1, 2012. Despite Dr. Amer's constant pleas for just recourse, Program Director Floyd Roberts denied Dr. Amer his legal right as a resident to appeal the termination decision violating hospital as well as ACGME policy.
Through sheer determination and hard work, Dr. Amer paid his way through medical school eventually earning his medical degree from Xavier University and gaining employment at Baton Rouge General Medical Center the first time he applied to the match, a rigorous and competitive process. In support of his dream, Dr. Amer and his wife quit their stable teaching jobs in New Orleans, left their comfortable home and moved with their two young children to Baton Rouge only to see Dr. Amer's dream disintegrate unjustly at the hands of spiteful and malicious program superiors in response to Dr. Amer's loyalty to the Hippocratic Oath he took upon graduating medical school to protect and serve his patients first as well as his adherence to ACGME policy which is aimed at protecting both residents and the public from unnecessary mistakes due to resident fatigue.
Reply
#2
For those who'd like to view the lawsuit click this link

http://batonrougegenerallawsuit.webs.com...awsuit.pdf
Reply
#3
good luck doc! i wish we could all stand together to speak up and reveal the corrupted system where they claim to be the best (and stop posting stupid hater messages).

This is being really ridiculous. They are ripping off our pockets, on top of it, they want them to be their poppet to use them and collect the money(such corrupted system use poor residents as a safety umbrella to cover up for the mess. so that they can make $$ and run the business). They hire low educated so called attending to back up each other and to kick out the smart ones when they get to know them . it is getting worse and worse!

i am sure there shud be more poor residents out there like this, and who prefer to shut up (fear of retaliation). i wish we could stand united to report such corruption which can benefit all of us.

we wont be safe even after match, because those who have stable job (such as these attending) can easily make up a story to kick us out.

i wish the best for this doctor. good job and hope he wins. i wish to see the result as well.
what is the name of this law firm?? I cant open the pdf?


Reply
#4
FRONT ROYAL -- A Front Royal doctor has been named as a defendant in a civil suit brought by a former resident physician.

Dr. Claudine Nigro is suing Dr. Francis X. Dennehy of Front Royal for breach of contract, defamation and emotional distress, according to papers filed Aug. 3 in U.S. District Court in Harrisonburg.

The Appalachian Osteopathic Postgraduate Training Institute, Warren Memorial Hospital, Valley Health System and Virginia Commonwealth University Medical College of Virginia also are named as defendants in the suit.

The suit claims that all defendants unlawfully refused to allow Nigro to progress to the residency program's second year.

Nigro originally enrolled in the three-year residency program in March 2008 for the term of a one-year period lasting from July 1, 2008, until June 30, 2009, the document states.

The lawsuit claims that in December, Nigro reported in a survey conducted by a residency program accrediting agency that she was being asked by the physicians to work hours exceeding set limits. Nigro contends that she was subjected to a series of retaliatory actions as a result of the disclosure, including harassment and defamation, that culminated with her resignation from the program.

In February, Dennehy began admonishing Nigro's work performance and required her to be evaluated for depression, according to the documents. Nigro complied with the request, and a psychiatric evaluation showed Nigro was not suffering from any mental condition. The results of the evaluation were sent to Dennehy on March 24.

Nigro was informed on March 25 that her residency would not be renewed, according to the suit. Nigro appealed the non-renewal action and a procedural subcommittee overturned the decision.

Following the appeal, Dennehy officially placed Nigro on probation in April, stipulating that she repeat the first year of the residency program and that she undergo monthly counseling, the suit states.

Believing the defendants exhibited a pattern of conduct indicating Nigro would not be treated fairly, she resigned from the program, according to the lawsuit.

Nigro is seeking $500,000 in compensatory damages jointly from each defendant for the violation of due process, $500,000 in compensatory damages jointly from each defendant for the breach of contract claim, $500,000 in compensatory damages and $500,000 in punitive damages jointly from each defendant for the defamation claim, and $1 million total in compensatory and punitive damages jointly from each defendant for the intentional infliction of emotional distress.

__________________
Reply
#5
Must be AMG b/c IMG will gratefully take it up the ***
Reply
#6
Sorry, the link was down for a bit. This one should work

http://batonrougegenerallawsuit.webs.com...wsuit3.pdf

It's quite interesting to celebrate the program's 1st year with a multi-million dollar lawsuit. I'm aware of Dr. Nigro's case as well as almost all the other cases out there on the internet including Dr. Serrano who sued Johns Hopkins for $24 million. Thank you rajji and sami for contributing to this discussion. We need all the help we can get. I shall update on the outcome of this suit as things move forward.

All the best to those who matched!
Reply
#7
Here is Dr. Serrano's case against JHU:
http://www.semmelweissociety3.net/oskarkserranomd/
Reply
#8
hope they can win it. it is not long enough that programs torture residents, abuse them, and fire them easily and no one dare to speak up or no one gives those poor hopeless resident a damn. someone must speak up against such shameful slavery set by some big giants in medicine.
Reply
#9
Well Dr. Serrano's case has already been settled out of court for an undisclosed amount of money, which is typical. Agreed residents should push back against this abusive environment in 'malignant' programs.

Anyone matched at BRG on this forum?
Reply
#10
Good luck. Hope you take them to the cleaner. BRG is a malignant program. I did a rotation there!
Reply
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »


Forum Jump: